I Took the Road Less Traveled By
A message out of nowhere
A few years ago I got a Facebook message out of nowhere.
It was from John, an old fraternity brother. We had not been in touch since college, over 20 years earlier. Nothing happened between us. We graduated, went our separate ways and got busy with life… which is what happens to most college friends.
The message was simple.
“Hey, Ray, do you live in Querétaro in Mexico?”
I remember looking at it for a second. It is a strange feeling when someone from a completely different part of your life shows up in your inbox like that. It is a bit like finding an old photo in a drawer. You know the person in it. You just are not sure you know them anymore.
So I wrote back.
“Hey, John, yeah. What’s up? It’s been a long time.”
It turned out John was in town for work. He was setting up manufacturing for the company he had worked at since college. One of the biggest car companies in the world. He had been there pretty much his entire career, and now that career had brought him to my city.
So we did what you do. We made plans to grab dinner.
The guy I almost drove past
I drove over to pick him up at his hotel.
And I almost drove right past him.
I am not exaggerating to make the story better. I was pulling up, looking for John, and my brain did not register that the man standing out front was the guy I was looking for. I only figured it out at the last second.
In college, John was a wrestler. He was in shape. The kind of shape you only get when someone is making you run and lift and cut weight every week.
The man in front of the hotel had a lot of white hair. He was not very overweight, but he was not in his old shape either. We are the same age. But if you had put the two of us side by side and asked a stranger to guess, most people would have said John was at least five years older than me.
I want to be careful here, because this is not a story about who aged better. I have my own collection of things that are not what they were at 20… my knees could give you the full list. Time happens to everybody. It just did not happen to us in the same way, and I noticed it before I even put the car in park.
That turned out to be the theme of the whole night.
Same people, same things
We sat down for dinner and started catching up.
It was good. Honestly, it was really good to see him. There is something about people who knew you before you were whoever you are now. They remember the version of you that had no idea what was coming.
But as the night went on, I started to notice something about John’s stories.
Most of them were about hanging out with the same people from college. Doing the same things. Every year.
The same group. The same trips. The same traditions. The guys I had lost touch with 20 years earlier were still the main characters in his life, and the stories had a kind of rhythm to them. This year we did this. Last year we did the same thing. Next year we are doing it again.
And I want to be very clear about something before I go any further.
I am sure John has an amazing life. He is married. He has kids. He is happy. He has a career he has stuck with since he was in his early twenties, which is more than most people can say. He has friends he has kept for over two decades. That is not nothing. That is a lot, actually.
This is not a story about John doing it wrong.
It is a story about what I saw sitting across the table from him.
The other track
What I saw was the life I could have had.
Not a guess about it. Not a theory. The actual thing, sitting in front of me, eating dinner.
Not a guess about it. Not a theory. The actual thing, sitting in front of me, eating dinner.
Because after college, I was on that exact track. I had a good job as a computer engineer. I had the condo, the TV and the car. I had friends I went to bars with. If you had drawn a line from where I was at 22 and extended it forward 20 years, it would have landed pretty close to where John was sitting.
The only reason it did not is that I quit. I left that job to join the Peace Corps and, eventually, become an entrepreneur.
If you read my last Notebook piece, you know how that happened. Three things in 72 hours. A night in a bar where I realized I did not want to be there 15 years later doing the same thing with the same people. A CEO handing a man a plaque and a watch for 30 years of service. And a Navy commercial asking if anyone would want to read the book of my life.
I remember thinking, back then, that I could see where that road went.
Sitting at dinner with John, I realized I had only been guessing. I had a picture in my head of the other road, but it was an imagined picture. A 26-year-old’s projection. John was the real version. Same starting point, same school, same age, roughly the same kind of beginning. Different fork.
Most people never get that. You make a big decision, and then you spend the rest of your life wondering what the other choice would have looked like. You build a story about it in your head, and the story is usually either much better or much worse than reality, depending on how your week is going.
I got to see it. Over a few hours and a plate of food.
Two roads
There is a poem I have loved for a long time. Robert Frost’s “The Road Not Taken.” It is one of my favorites.
You probably know the ending, even if you do not know the rest.
Two roads diverged in a wood, and I—
I took the one less traveled by,
And that has made all the difference.
For years my own version of that line was something like, “I did take the road less traveled by, and I’m better for it.”
I still believe the second half of that, for me. But the dinner with John made me think harder about it.
Here is the thing people tend to miss about the poem. Earlier in it, Frost admits the two roads were actually pretty similar. He says the passing there “had worn them really about the same.” Both looked fair. He picked one. And then he says that someday, “ages and ages hence,” he will be telling the story with a sigh, and in that story the choice will have made all the difference.
I read that differently now than I did at 26.
At 26, I read it as a victory lap. Pick the weird road, win the game.
Now I read it as something more honest. You stand at the fork. You cannot see very far down either path. You pick one. And then, because you only get to live one life, you cannot ever really compare. The road you took becomes the story you tell.
Except, every so often, life hands you a look at the other road.
For me, that look came in the form of a Facebook message and a guy with white hair standing in front of a hotel.
Very different people, very different lives
We talked for three or four hours.
Then we said goodbye.
It was genuinely great to see him. I mean that. But I also remember thinking, on the drive home, that another hour or two and we probably would have run out of things to talk about.
Not because anything was wrong. Because we had become very different people who had led very different lives.
He had 20 years of the same people and the same traditions. I had 20 years of moving countries, starting things, breaking things, and starting them again. When you only have the first 20 years in common, and then 20 years on very different roads, you can fill a good dinner. Maybe not a whole weekend.
That is not sad. It is just true. And it does not make one life better or worse than the other.
That is the part I keep coming back to.
I could tell this story in a way that makes me sound clever. Look at me, I took the road less traveled, look how it worked out. I am not going to do that, because I do not think it is the lesson. John is happy. I am happy. We are both, as far as I can tell, living lives we would choose again.
The difference is not that my road was better.
The difference is that I got to see his.
The difference is not that my road was better. The difference is that I got to see his.
What this means if you build things
If you are a founder, or thinking about becoming one, I think there is something useful in this. Not a rule. More of an observation.
When you are on the entrepreneur road, it is very easy to romanticize the other one. The steady paycheck. The same friends for 20 years. The trips that happen every year without you having to build anything to pay for them. On a bad week, and there are plenty of bad weeks, that road looks pretty good.
And when you are on the steady road, it is just as easy to romanticize this one. The freedom. The stories. The upside. On a boring week, the other side looks like an adventure movie.
Both of those pictures are mostly made up. They are guesses, built from what you are unhappy about this week.
What actually helps, I think, is getting a real look at the other road when you can. Talk to the people who took the fork you did not. Not to keep score. To see it clearly. It tends to do two things at once. It takes the shine off the fantasy, and it reminds you why you picked the road you are on.
That dinner did both for me.
It made me grateful for the choice I made at 26. Not because John’s life is worse. Because when I looked at his life honestly, I could see it was not the book I wanted to write. It is a good book. It is just not mine.
It is a good book. It is just not mine.
And it made me a bit more humble about that choice too. I did not pick the better road. I picked the road that fit me. That is all any of us can really do.
I did not pick the better road. I picked the road that fit me. That is all any of us can really do.
The question still works
My old question from that condo in Cleveland still holds up.
If they were to write a book about your life, would anybody want to read it?
The dinner with John added a second question for me.
If you got to see the other book, the one where you made the other choice, would you trade?
For me, the answer was no. Not because his book is bad. Because I already know how much I like the one I am in.
You might get a different answer. That is fine. That is kind of the point. The poem does not tell you which road to take. It just tells you that you will take one, and that it will make the difference.
So if an old friend ever shows up in your messages out of nowhere, asking if you still live in some city… go to dinner.
You might almost drive past them. Pull over anyway.
If you have ever had your own version of this dinner, where you got a look at the road you did not take, I would love to hear about it. Just hit reply, no pressure at all.
Talk to you soon,
Ray Blakney